Vote Chori: Records of Votes Cast After 5 PM Missing in 200 Constituencies During 2024 Elections: Investigative Report

New Delhi | November 19, 2026 | DeccanLive.com
Serious questions have been raised about the transparency of India’s 2024 elections after an investigative report revealed that records of votes cast after 5 PM are missing in 200 constituencies across Maharashtra, Haryana and Jammu and Kashmir.
According to media reports, the Election Commission of India (ECI) does not have data in its internal records showing how many voters cast their votes after 5 PM in these 200 constituencies during the 2024 Assembly and Lok Sabha elections.
The findings were revealed in an investigative report published by The Reporters’ Collective, an independent investigative journalism organisation.
The report says that the absence of these records means the Election Commission has no way to properly check what happened at polling booths during the final hour of voting and after the scheduled closing time of 6 PM in these constituencies.
Records of 4,212 Documents Examined
The Reporters’ Collective examined 4,212 official documents prepared by Returning Officers from 467 Assembly constituencies and 63 Lok Sabha constituencies.
These are official election records that are not routinely made available to the public by the Election Commission.
Of the 200 constituencies where data on voting after 5 PM was missing, Maharashtra accounted for the highest number, with 132 constituencies.
These included:
Maharashtra: Records were missing for 114 of the 288 Assembly constituencies and 18 of the 48 Lok Sabha constituencies.
Jammu and Kashmir: Records were missing for 44 of the 90 Assembly constituencies and one of the five Lok Sabha constituencies.
Haryana: Records were missing for 22 of the 90 Assembly constituencies and one of the 10 Lok Sabha constituencies.
The investigative team had sought records for a total of 531 constituencies. However, it could not obtain the records for the Devsar constituency in Jammu and Kashmir.
Election Commission Rules Require Regular Recording of Votes
According to the Election Commission’s own rules, the Presiding Officer at every polling booth must record the total number of votes registered in the Electronic Voting Machine (EVM) every two hours until the end of polling.
These figures must be entered in the Presiding Officer’s Diary.
The rules also state that these figures must match the details recorded in Form 17-A, the register in which every voter entering the polling booth is recorded separately.
The figures in both records must match at every two-hour interval and at the end of polling.
The report points out that failing to maintain the final voting figures amounts to a violation of the Election Commission’s own rules.
Missing Data Raises Questions About Final Hour of Voting
On polling day, the Election Commission headquarters receives only brief, booth-wise reports showing the overall voting figures. These reports do not provide enough information to understand what happened at an individual polling booth after 5 PM.
However, the report says that the absence of final-hour voting data across all polling booths in 200 constituencies should have raised serious concerns.
According to the investigation, the final hours of polling are considered particularly sensitive because polling agents representing smaller or weaker political parties may have already left the booths by then. This could make it easier for electoral irregularities to take place.
The issue is also important because the Election Commission has repeatedly maintained that voter turnout figures released on polling day are only provisional and may change later.
Opposition Parties Had Raised Allegations of Fake Voting
Since the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, opposition parties have repeatedly raised allegations of fake voting after 5 PM.
The issue became particularly controversial during the Maharashtra Assembly elections held on November 20, 2024.
At 5 PM on polling day, the office of the Maharashtra Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) reported a voter turnout of 58.22 per cent.
However, the figure was increased to 66.05 per cent the following day. This meant an increase of nearly 76 lakh votes, an unusually large rise.
At the time, Maharashtra Chief Electoral Officer S. Chockalingam explained that the increase was due to voters who were standing in queues after 5 PM and were allowed to cast their votes.
According to the investigation, the 174 Maharashtra Assembly constituencies for which post-5 PM records were available recorded a total of 50.87 lakh votes after 5 PM.
Eknath Shinde’s Constituency Among the Examples
The report highlighted the Kopri-Pachpakhadi Assembly constituency in Thane as one example.
In this constituency, Shiv Sena leader Eknath Shinde defeated Shiv Sena (UBT) candidate Kedar Dighe by a margin of more than 1.20 lakh votes.
By 5 PM, around 1.13 lakh votes had been recorded in the constituency. However, the final voting figure reached 2.03 lakh.
According to calculations by The Reporters’ Collective, this means that 89,878 votes were cast after 5 PM across 366 polling booths.
This works out to an average of around four votes per minute at each polling booth during the period after 5 PM.
Records of Voters Waiting in Queues Also Missing
The investigation also found that in 23 out of the 530 constituencies examined, election officials had not recorded how many voting slips were issued to people standing in queues when polling officially closed at 6 PM.
According to election rules, when polling time ends, officials must issue signed slips to all voters waiting in the queue. The process must begin with the person standing at the end of the queue.
After the official closing time, only voters holding these slips are allowed to cast their votes.
However, because records of the number of slips issued are missing in these 23 constituencies, the Election Commission is now unable to verify whether only authorised voters were allowed to vote after the scheduled closing time.
The findings have raised fresh questions about election record-keeping, transparency and the Election Commission’s ability to verify voting activity during the final hours of polling.



