US Azaan Controversy: Journalist Mehdi Hasan Clashes with Congressman Over Religious Freedom

Washington | October 24, 2025 | www.deccanlive.com

A heated debate has erupted in the United States over the Azaan (Islamic call to prayer), raising serious questions about religious freedom and cultural identity. The clash between British-born American journalist Mehdi Hasan and Congressman Brandon Gill has turned into a major social media storm.

The controversy began when Mehdi Hasan voiced support for allowing the Azaan in the US. He said, “If church bells can ring, then the Azaan can also be called.” Hasan, who is the Editor-in-Chief and CEO of Zeteo, further stated, “We are just as American as you are, and we will not tolerate anyone’s nonsense.” His statement emphasized religious equality and the right to cultural expression.

Reacting sharply, Congressman Brandon Gill posted a sarcastic comment on social media platform X (formerly Twitter): “We can come here in large numbers and fundamentally change the American public landscape.” His statement reflected a divisive attitude toward immigrants and minorities.

Hasan responded by pointing out Gill’s own family background, writing: “Your wife is an Indian-American, the daughter of an Indian immigrant.” The journalist’s response highlighted the double standards often present in anti-immigrant rhetoric.

Gill then replied, “My wife is a Christian, and she doesn’t want to hear your oppressive Muslim call to prayer. If you want to live in a Muslim country, go back to the UK.” The remark has been widely condemned as an example of religious intolerance and an attempt to mix personal bias with public discourse.

The exchange quickly went viral, prompting a wave of reactions online. Many users supported Mehdi Hasan, arguing that both church bells and Azaan fall under the First Amendment’s protection of religious freedom.

One user commented, “If church bells are allowed, the Azaan should be too—it’s the same principle of faith expression.” Another wrote, “A Christian who shows no tolerance or compassion goes against the very teachings of Christianity.”

The debate has now become part of a larger discussion in the US about religious equality, minority rights, and the meaning of true freedom in a diverse nation.